2013/05/07

Offiziere.ch: "Americans, Afghans and Battlefield Agility"

 
The Afghan soldiers sprint ahead, exposed to any bombs but unafraid. U.S. squad leader Sgt. Mason Mullins yells to them to slow down. “We don’t move that fast!”
Time and again this happens: the Afghans outpace the Americans and the Americans must reel them back in. The pace of the raid slows even further when the combined patrol rounds up several Afghan villagers and must enroll them in a biometric database using wireless devices that take 20 minutes to boot up.
By the time they surround Mohammad’s brother’s compound, the Taliban commander and his host are long gone — apparently having fled on a motorbike.
Offiziere.ch

This happens when troops know that the war is not worth their sacrifice (or much else).

The real problem isn't mission failure in an unimportant land-locked country far, far away. The real problem is that a generation of Western army troops and in other ways also Western combat aviation have become used to such a mode of warfare. A mode they won't see again when sometime in the -hopefully distant- future there's a war that can actually remind us why a great part of the peacetime budgets and peacetime efforts for improvement, improvement, improvement* were justified.


S O

*: (or at least matching the levels of performance demonstrated by ancestors)

5 comments:

  1. An insightful article by David Axe. I tip my hat! I suppose he really has more to contribute as an embedded journo than on geopolitical and strategic issues.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The first positive comment about the Afghans not on the insurgent side.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You haven't been looking, then. Reporting about ANA takes two forms: articles like this praising their bravery and how well they're learning from the OMLTs and how great it is to have locals on our side and fighting well enough, and there are many articles like this. And then there are many more articles about "green on blue" and forum postings from servicemen failing to understand that Afghans have no (military) cultural history derived from the Prussian drillmasters of the 1700s.

      Delete
    2. Look who's arriving off-road on motorbikes in this NATO video:
      http://youtu.be/onNKut6lIfQ?t=2m20s

      Delete
    3. Sorry, I forgot the necessary evils. The Russians have a nice expression for articles that are sent pre-written to journalists.

      Delete

Use a nickname and stick to it! I may block anonymous comments. Offensive comments may also be blocked, in part due to the duties of a blogger in Germany.